Free US Shipping On Orders Over $99
Free US Shipping On Orders Over$99

The Case for Jesus Course Introduction: Bart Ehrman and the Transfiguration of Jesus on the Mountain (Part 3 of 5)

by Brant Pitre May 02, 2016 0 Comments



< Watch Part 2     Watch Part 4 >



In this video excerpt, which is part 3 of 5, taken from The Case for Jesus: The Reliability of the Gospels and the Jewish Roots of Jesus' Divinity, Dr. Brant Pitre continues his critique of skeptical scholars (e.g., Bart Ehrman and others) who claim that Jesus was not a divine Messiah in the synoptic Gospels (Matthew, Mark, and Luke). Dr. Pitre does so in this video by following up on the last video with some final comments about the the walking on the water scene and with the divine Jesus you find at the theophany of the Transfiguration, as depicted in the synoptic Gospels.

Following up with the Walking on Water: One element that the Gospel of John gives us about this account that the synoptics do not is that Jesus was about 4 miles out in the Sea of Galilee, which is roughly 7 miles wide at its widest point. This small element further enforces the miraculous nature of the walking on water, for Jesus was not simply walking out on a sandbar near the shore or surfing on sheets of ice -- he was effectively in the middle of the Sea of Galilee, walking on water. Moreover, Matthew also gives us an extra detail stating that the Apostles began to worship him when they got back into the boat, which is the very thing that Jesus told the devil in his temptations in the desert earlier in the Gospel of Matthew that was owed to God alone. So the question remains: Why does Jesus accept the worship of his disciples if he's not divine when that is precisely what he states is due to God alone earlier in the very same Gospel?

The Transfiguration: In Mark 9, at the mount of the transfiguration with Peter, James and John, Jesus is not just revealing his power to his disciples, but is performing a theophany, when read in context. In this scene, Moses and Elijah appear, who are two figures in the Old Testament who did not get to see the face of God (Cf. Exodus 33 and 1Kings 19) -- they hid and covered their faces in the theophanies of the Old Testament when God passed them by. But, now it is in the Glory Cloud (Shekinah) of the Old Testament that Jesus reveals God's face to Moses and Elijah, and Moses and Elijah are finally able to see the face of the God whose face they could not see in their earthly life. In Jesus of Nazareth, God now has a face that these two figures longed to see.

Finally, Dr. Pitre asks, "How does Ehrman get around this?" For, in fact, Bart Ehrman, in his book, How Jesus became God, quoted by Dr. Pitre in this video, acknowledges that Jesus is divine in the synoptic Gospels and performs divine acts. But, Bart Ehrman then resorts not to denying that we have a divine Jesus in the synoptics (which he does earlier in the same book), but that it is the "anonymous" authors of the Gospels who made him divine (i.e., invented his divine identity) when penning the Gospels.

Thus, we have something of a fallacy of begging the question (Petitio Principii) happening with Bart Ehrman's book. Effectively, the circle goes like this:

(1) We know Jesus was not divine in the synoptics, according to Bart Ehrman.

And, how do we know that?

(2) Because there is no evidence for it, according to Bart Ehrman...except for the evidence that is there expressing Jesus' divinity. But, in those instances where Jesus is made out to be divine in the synoptics, we know it was simply made up, retroactively sensationalized and applied to the real, historical Jesus.

And, how do we know that?

(3) Because we know that Jesus was not divine, especially in the synoptics.

Therefore, to assert the argument, Jesus was not divine in the synoptics we must either ignore the evidence that is there or run into the circular argument as to why it was made up, assuming the very thing needed to be established.

You can find more videos and comment on this one at blog.catholicproductions.com.

You can also find Dr. Pitre's Bible studies on cd/dvd/mp3 and signed books at https://store.catholicproductions.com/collections/brant-pitre



Brant Pitre
Brant Pitre

Author


★★★★★ Reviews

Letting Customers Speak for Us

4142 reviews
94%
(3881)
3%
(134)
1%
(51)
0%
(11)
2%
(65)
The Dead Sea Scrolls for Catholics

Doctor Bergman's delivery of this topic is very good, and easy to listen to. I enjoy his insights and his sense of humor.

The delivery of the package left a lot to be desired...it took from April 16 to May 4th to get to us. In todays' next day delivery environment it leaves a lot to be desired. A warning on your website that delivery of a letter-sized package can take over two weeks to be delivered would lower expectations and increase customer satisfaction.

I am very sorry for the shipping delay. The post office in the New Orleans area has been struggling lately, which causes packages to sit in one place for a week before being moved along in the process. We have spoken to them regarding this and hope they can get it resolved soon

The Hidden King: The Jewish Roots of St. Joseph

Fr Donald Calloway ( author of Consecration To St. Joseph) highly recommended this lesson !!! He said Brant Pitre , Knocks it Out of the Park !!!!! He was extremely excited about the info included inside. He loved it !!! I have to agree !!! This was an incredible experience ! Extremely interesting !!!! If you have a love for St Joseph & want to learn more. This is a great teaching !!! What better time to learn than this year ... The year of St Joseph !!! Ite ad Ioseph !!!

From NZ

Looking forward to the books arriving. Thanks

Great Information on the greatest male Saint

This was such a great series to purchase. Saint Joseph is my patron saint. I learned so much from this talk. One thing I learned is that Saint Joseph was not old as many pictures show him to be. What a refreshing series. Learning about Jesus more through Joseph. Saint Joseph also would have given Jesus his name. Powerful talks. Consider purchasing this series; it will help you grow more in your culture and faith.

The 4th Cup

Tremendous!