The shortest Eucharistic Prayer is also one of the oldest — and its origins are more dramatic than most Catholics realize. Dr. Brant Pitre uncovers where Eucharistic Prayer II actually comes from.
Eucharistic Prayer II: History, Biblical Roots, and Meaning
Of the four Eucharistic Prayers, this is the shortest and the one the Church recommends for weekdays (GIRM 365). Dr. Pitre explains its distinctive history: it is modeled on the third-century Eucharistic Prayer attributed to St. Hippolytus of Rome — the earliest anaphora to come down to us — and was assembled for the reformed Missal by Bernard Botte and Louis Bouyer under St. Paul VI. He sets the Missal text side by side with Hippolytus so viewers can see what was retained and what was new. Biblically, the session follows the manna and "dewfall" imagery ("by sending down your Spirit upon them like the dewfall," cf. Exodus 16) into John 6's Bread of Life and the "chalice of salvation" of Psalm 116, with St. Ambrose and St. John of Damascus on the mystery. Dr. Pitre even reads Bouyer's own candid memoir about how quickly the final edits of the prayer were performed. The video maps this territory and raises the questions; it saves the full synthesis for the session.
Key passages & sources examined: GIRM 365; Roman Missal, Order of Mass nos. 99-106; Exodus 16:14-15; John 6:48-51; Psalm 116:13-17; St. Hippolytus, Apostolic Tradition (3rd c.); St. Ambrose, On the Sacraments; St. John of Damascus, On the Orthodox Faith; Louis Bouyer, Memoirs
Where did Eucharistic Prayer 2 come from? It is based on the third-century anaphora sometimes attributed to St. Hippolytus of Rome and was drafted for the modern Missal by scholars commissioned by Paul VI, such as Botte and Bouyer. The video compares the two texts line by line.
Why is Eucharistic Prayer II used on weekdays? It is the shortest of the four, and the Church proposes it for weekday and special-circumstance Masses (GIRM 365). Dr. Pitre discusses why in the session.
What does "like the dewfall" mean in Eucharistic Prayer 2? The phrase draws on the manna that came with the dew in Exodus 16; the session traces that image into John 6.
Want every Sunday and feast explained like this?
Get Dr. Brant Pitre’s complete Mass Readings Explained — a new study for every Sunday and holy day.
Once logged in, you can access everything by going to 'Membership' in the main menu bar of our website, then 'Mass Readings Explained' and then pick one of the options there. The calendar view works well for finding those Mass Readings that are in the near future and The Mass Explained will take you to videos in that series.
I love getting the mass readings/readings explained, every week. Dr Brandt Petrie it’s truly amazing in his knowledge of the Old Testament and the New Testament.!
I’ve subscribed for many years and have shared Brant Pitre’s excellent work as gifts to friends and colleagues around the world. Keep up the good work. Team!
Once logged in, you can access everything by going to 'Membership' in the main menu bar of our website, then 'Mass Readings Explained' and then pick one of the options there. The calendar view works well for finding those Mass Readings that are in the near future and The Mass Explained will take you to videos in that series.
I love getting the mass readings/readings explained, every week. Dr Brandt Petrie it’s truly amazing in his knowledge of the Old Testament and the New Testament.!
I’ve subscribed for many years and have shared Brant Pitre’s excellent work as gifts to friends and colleagues around the world. Keep up the good work. Team!